Where Classy Meets Casual
Welcome! We are excited you chose to dine with us.
Please note that due to our VERY small kitchen, dining at Water Street is a destination as well as an experience. Due to our popularity, it is not uncommon for tables to wait an extended time for both appetizers and entrees. We kindly ask for your patience and assure you that your meals will be worth the wait.
STARTERS
Calamari
$16.00
Flour dusted and served with a Thai chili sauce
Crab Crostini
$21.00
Rustic crostini topped with jumbo lump crab meat and finished with a brown sugar apricot brandy sauce
Honey Glazed Fried Brussels
$12.00
Glazed with warm honey, topped with candied walnuts and crumbled feta GF
Fried Oysters
$15.00
Hand breaded and served with tartar sauce
Crab Hush Puppies
$16.00
Cornmeal batter, crab, scallions, Old Bay
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
$19.00
Scallops wrapped in bacon, served with an orange mango sauce GF
Chesapeake Fondue
$18.00
Served in a bread bowl with melted cheese, lump crab, Maryland spices and pretzel bites
Crab Deviled Eggs
$18.00
House-made and topped with jumbo lump crab and applewood bacon GF
Rockfish Tenders
$15.00
Mini rockfish filets, battered, fried, served with creole mayo
Fried Shrimp
$15.00
Breaded, served with cocktail sauce
Tuna Carpaccio
$22.00
Ahi tuna topped with capers, peppery arugula, Parmesan drizzled with EVO and a squeeze of lemon juice GF
Bruschetta Trio
$22.00
*Filet, arugula, horseradish cream *Heirloom tomato, basil vinaigrette, feta cheese *Prosciutto, avocado, fresh mozzarella
SOUPS
Cream of Crab
-Award Winning!
$11.00
Shrimp Gumbo
$13.00
Oyster Stew GF
$15.00
SALADS
Harvest Spinach
$15.00
Baby spinach, candied walnuts, apples, dried cranberries, crumbled feta, maple-balsamic dressing GF
Caesar
$14.00
Romaine, Caesar dressing and finished with Parmesan cheese and croutons
GF without croutons
Cobb Salad
$16.00
Romaine lettuce, avocado, bacon, chopped egg, tomato, and blue cheese crumbles GF
Turn any salad into a meal: Shrimp Salad - 12 Crabcake - 21 Grilled Shrimp - 11 Salmon - 13 Chicken - 10 Salad Dressings: *House Honey Lemon *House Blue Cheese *House Maple Balsamic *Ranch *Raspberry Walnut Vinaigrette
STEAMED & GRILLED
Prince Edward Island Mussels
$15.00
Garlic butter wine or marinara sauce, served with toast points
GF without toast points
Char Grilled Oysters
$15.00
Lemon, creole butter, Parmesan cheese, topped with bread crumbs and grilled to perfection
Middleneck Clams
$16.00
One dozen, in a garlic butter wine sauce, toast points
GF without toast points
Steamed Trio
$18.00
Shrimp, mussels, clams, steamed in a garlic butter wine sauce. Served with toast points GF without toast points
Peel & Eat Shrimp 1/2lb - $15
1lb - $27
Steamed with onions, and Old Bay. Served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge GF
Snow Crab Legs
2 clusters - MP 3 clusters - MP
$
Steamed Maryland style with Old Bay GF
RAW BAR
Salt Buoy Oysters
$ 2.50 a shuck
Sustainably raised in coastal bay waters, these oysters are naturally purified by the tides and finish with a delicate hint of melon. GF
Oyster Flight
$25.00
Choose 4 of the 5 IPA, Dirty Martini, Bloody Mary, Cucumber Martini, Blackberry Jalapeno Mimosa GF
Chef’s Featured Oysters
MP
East & West Coast oysters, our selection changes daily. Shucked to order with your choice of cocktail, mignonette or horseradish GF
Middleneck Clams
½ dz - $9 dz - $18
Served raw with cocktail sauce GF
Kitchen Love
RARELY do these men and women get the gratitude they deserve, even a small gesture like ringing the kitchen bell will make their night. Feeling a bit more generous, feel free to leave a few bills in the kitchen bin because Magic doesn’t make the food so delicious - the chefs do!!
HANDHELDS
Served with kettle chips and a pickle Substitute fries - 3
Swamp Wrap
$20.00
Chicken, shrimp, Andouille sausage, rice, cheddar
Salmon BLT Wrap
$16.00
Baked salmon, bacon, lettuce, tomato, remoulade sauce
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$15.00
Chicken tenders, lettuce, buffalo sauce, crumbled blue cheese dressing
Shrimp Salad Wrap
$16.00
Shrimp, Old Bay mayo, lettuce
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$15.00
Grilled chicken, crisp romaine, Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing
Crab Cake Sandwich
$24.00
Broiled, served on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato
Oyster Po Boy
$17.00
Fried oysters tucked into a toasted Milano roll, topped with lettuce and Cajun mayo
Shrimp Po Boy
$17.00
Crispy Gulf-style shrimp on a toasted Milano roll, with lettuce and Cajun mayo
Seafood Cheesesteak
$22.00
Scallops, crab, shrimp, and cheese, topped with Mornay sauce, served on a toasted Milano roll
BASKETS
Fish & Chips
$24.00
Beer battered cod, flash fried, tartar sauce
Fried Shrimp
$24.00
Eight jumbo shrimp, lightly breaded, served with cocktail sauce
Served with french fries
and coleslaw
Fried Oysters
$24.00
Eight Chesapeake selects, lightly hand breaded, Cajun tartar sauce
Susky Sampler
$24.00
Rockfish tenders, fried shrimp, fried oysters, crab hush puppies
BUILD YOUR OWN
Served with kettle chips and a pickle Substitute fries - 3
PROTEIN
Smash Burger: Two 4oz Angus Burgers
Grilled or Blackend Chicken Breast: 6 oz $ 15.00
TOPPINGS
Lettuce I Tomato I Sliced Red Onion I Bacon +2 Sauteed Mushrooms +2 I Mini Crabcake + 10 I Andouille +6
CHEESES
*American *Cheddar *Swiss *Provolone
FROM LAND TO SEA
Served with two sides
Atlantic Salmon
$24.00
Grilled or blackened
Salmon Milano
$26.00
Topped with pesto, parmesan and bread crumbs
Sea Bass
$38.00
Pan seared or blackened
Maryland Crabcakes Single:
$29.00
Broiled 5 oz crabcake Double: $50.00
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
$29.00
Lightly fried & served with an orange mango sauce GF
Served with two sides
Porter House Pork Chop GF
$28.00
12 oz chop, ever-evolving in presentation. Ask your server about this week’s creation
Chicken Chesapeake GF
$28.00
Chicken breast, lump crab meat, Mornay sauce
Butcher’s Cut GF
MP
Grilled I Blackened
Served with a House or Caesar Salad
Water Street Cioppino
$34.00
Fresh fish, scallops, clams, mussels, calamari, and shrimp in an aromatic tomato broth Add linguine - 3 $ 34.00 GF without toast points or linguine
Jambalaya
$28.00
Shrimp, chicken, Andouille sausage tossed with okra, peppers, onions, and creole-seasoned rice GF
Seabass Florentine
$43.00
Infused with zesty lemon and aromatic garlic, paired with creamy sauteed spinach and clams GF
PASTA
Served with a House or Caesar Salad
Shrimp & Crab Linguine
$31.00
Jumbo shrimp, lump crab, tomatoes, herbed wine sauce
Salt Life Pasta
$34.00
Shrimp, lump crab, scallops, linguine, tossed in a creamy Old Bay alfredo or marinara
Linguine with Clams
$28.00
Fresh clams steamed and tossed in garlic butter wine or marinara
STEAMER POTS
Low Country Shrimp Boil
Shrimp, andouille sausage, potatoes, corn, Old Bay, topped with garlic butter - 30 GF
Ocean’s Bounty
1 snow crab cluster, shrimp, mussels, clams, andouille sausage, potatoes, corn, Old Bay, topped with garlic butter - 50 GF
Snow Crab Steamer
2 snow crab clusters, andouille sausage, potatoes, corn, Old Bay, topped with garlic butter - 44 GF
KIDS MENU
Includes a juice box or soda, warm brownie with whipped cream and sprinkles. All meals except pasta come with fries or vegetable
BEVERAGES
Fountain Soda - $3.00
Unsweet Tea, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Coke, Diet Coke, Lemonade
Club Soda - $3.00
Child’s Juice Box - $2.00
Spindrift: Raspberry- Lime - $3.00 Spindrift: Lemon - $3.00
Sparkling Water - $3.00
Cheeseburger - 10
Steamed Shrimp - 14
Fried Shrimp - 14
Chicken Tenders - 12
Pasta Marinara - 12
Buttered Pasta - 12
Fish & Chips - 14
SIDES
Fries - $6.00
Fresh Vegetable - $5.00
Rice Pilaf - $3.00
Cole Slaw - $3.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes - $4.00
Fried Brussels - $5.00
Side Pasta - $6.00
Side Salad - $4.00
-
Ask to substitute pasta with Palmini (hearts of palm): 8g per serving, 40 calories per serving, gluten free, non GMO - 4
-
Consuming raw or under cooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your chance of food-borne illnesses.
-
Please note that due to market fluctuations prices posted on the menu may change without notice.
-
While we strive to do our best we have not conquered perfection. If you are unsatisfied with your meal or service please ask to see a manager before becoming a keyboard warrior. Nine times out of ten we can fix the problem before you leave!
-
20% gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more guests.
-
Due to rising costs, if you choose to use a credit card we will charge a 3% convenience fee. This amount is not more than what we pay in processing fees. If you do not wish to pay a convenience fee feel free to use CASH or DEBIT cards.